How does personality and taste enter
in to getting published?
Actually it is very important. A
number of years ago I was at a conference at Texas A & M and sat in a
workshop on communication. That was in the 70’s and he gave an illustration that
has stuck with me to this day.
He said to imagine that we had a box
with index cards in it. (OK, today this would probably be a computer file.) On
these index cards were written the sum total of our life experiences and
background. A card would have our family background and upraising, another our
education, our faith and beliefs, and on and on with all of the aspects of our
Now imagine that everyone has such a
box. Before we write something, or communicate with anyone in any manner we
thumb through the box and frame our communication according to the cards, we
frame it in terms of our knowledge and life experiences.
The problem is that the person or
persons that we are trying to communicate with have totally different boxes
that they will thumb through and will use to decipher our writing or message.
We will be successful in our writing and in our communication to the degree
that we are able to find common ground with the maximum number of people.
That puts a whole new face on it,
doesn’t it? But let me be more specific about submissions for publication. I’m
likely to want to work with a project if the author and I find this common
ground. They seem like a person I would want to work with. Then there is the
project itself, is it something I really relate to? Do I like it, enjoy reading
it, or more importantly do I really want to try and get it into print? That’s
where personality and taste enter in, I relate to the author and to the
But it doesn’t end there. If I take
it on I am then faced with finding the right acquisition editors. Again, are
they people that I relate to well, is there a personality fit? More important
do we have similar tastes? Just because I really like something doesn’t mean it
fits a particular editors taste and they like it as well. Cultivating these
editors with similar tastes is an ongoing process.
The most important thing is stellar
writing, but the path to publication is through people. And there personality
and taste matter.